You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Should a numeral before the comma count as a name word? (Dumas VI, Jr. gives no family name, Dumas III, Jr. gives family Dumas) #893
Background. To read a part before a comma, the parser counts its name words (rules/C3). AGENTS.md describes the count this way: a particle run and the word it attaches to count as one word; a connective join and a bound given-name pair count as their words (#613, so Ortega y Gasset, Jr. reads as a whole name); and a suffix beside the surname counts as no name word. A shape-only numeral (VI to X) and a chained salutation's connectives are counted as name words today, though they aren't:
Input
Master
Dumas III, Jr.
family Dumas, suffix III, Jr.
Dumas VI, Jr.
given Dumas, suffix VI, Jr., no family (reports suffix-or-name, given-or-family)
Mr. and Mrs. and Dr., Jr.
title only, suffix Jr.
Dumas VI, John
family Dumas, given John, suffix VI (fine: the given part supplies a given name)
The difference shows only when the part after the comma holds no given name: a generation word, or since #890 a gated agnomen (Dumas VI, Filho). #890's review found it, and it is older than #890.
How often: among comma-bearing local-corpus names, a two-word head ending in a numeral is common in FEC (2,431, nearly all SMITH III, JOHN), but VI to X there is 5 in FEC and 1 in ClinicalTrials.gov, and none of those has a part after the comma without a given name (counted 2026-10-25).
Questions
Should C3's count ask the numeral predicate (reads_as_generation, Ask one predicate for every roman-numeral rule (#752, phase 2f) #886) and count a numeral it reads as a generation as no name word, as it already counts a listed suffix? Then Dumas VI, Jr. reads as Dumas III, Jr. does.
Activity